By “South Park” is an animated sitcom that airs on Comedy Central, and centers on the happenings of four foul-mouthed fourth graders in a small mountain town in Colorado. As the District Court in Brownmark Films, LLC v. Comedy Partners stated, in the nearly 15 years that South Park has been on the air, “the four central characters have, amongst other adventures, battled space aliens, hunted Osama Bin Ladin in the wake of 9/11 ala Elmer Fudd and Bugs Bunny, and have, more recently, resolved the nation’s economic woes by charging the nation’s consumer debts on one of the character’s credit card.” Brownmark Films, LLC, v. Comedy Partners, 2011 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 72684 (E.D. Wis. July 6, 2011) (“Brownmark”).
The entities involved in the production of South Park found themselves in the middle of a copyright infringement suit because of a South Park episode entitled “Canada on Strike,” which allegedly infringed on Plaintiff Brownmark Films, LLC’s (“Plaintiff” or “Brownmark”) copyright in WWITB (defined below). In that episode, the naïve “Butters Stotch” (one of the South Park characters) is coaxed by his fellow classmates to record an internet video in the hopes of making money on the Internet. The Internet video replicates parts of the “What What (In the Butt)” (“WWITB”) video, which was a copyrighted video. The Court described the WWITB music video as “a nearly four minute ditty regarding the derriere of the singer of the underlying work.” The Court further explained: “The music video begins with an array of bizarre imagery—from a burning cross to a floating pink zeppelin—and only gets stranger from there. The heart of the video features an adult African American male ensconced in a bright red, half-buttoned, silk shirt, dancing, grinning creepily at the camera, and repeatedly singing the same cryptic phrases: ‘I said, what what, in the butt.’ And “you want to do it in my butt, in my butt.’” Brownmark, the purported co-owner of a copyright in the WWITB music video, filed suit against various entities involved in the production of South Park, alleging copyright infringement. According to Brownmark, the “Canada on Strike” episode has an internet video—which lasts for 58 seconds of the approximately 25 minute episode—replicating parts of the WWITB video, with the 9 year old Butters “singing the central lines of the original video, while dressed as a teddy bear, an astronaut, and even as a daisy.” As the Court noted, “[i]n the episode, Butters’ video, much like the original WWITB video, goes ‘viral,’ with millions watching the clip. However, after their attempts to collect ‘internet money’ prove fruitless, the South Park fourth graders learn that their video, much like other inane viral YouTube clips, have very little value to those who create the work.” The defendants justified their use by claiming “fair use,” which is an affirmative defense to copyright infringement.
By 
By